Still at the scrutiny stage? An ASMT-10 or DRC-01A that has not yet become a demand is answered by our GST notice reply service. This page covers contested matters: DRC-01 adjudication, Section 73/74/74A demands, Section 129 detention appeals, APL-01 first appeals and APL-05 appeals before the GSTAT Chennai Bench.
What is GST litigation?
GST litigation covers every stage of a tax dispute with the GST department: replying to a show-cause notice, departmental audit and assessment, a first appeal to the Appellate Authority within three months, and a second appeal to the GST Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT), which has Tamil Nadu benches at Chennai, Coimbatore and Madurai. How the first reply is handled often decides whether the matter ends quickly or runs for years.
Official references: CGST Act and Rules (cbic-gst.gov.in) · GST Portal user guide: Filing an Appeal against a Demand Order · GSTAT State Benches (gstat.gov.in)
Under Section 116 of the CGST Act, a practising Chartered Accountant is a statutorily recognised authorised representative and can appear and argue on your behalf before GST officers, the Appellate Authority, and the GST Appellate Tribunal, without requiring a separate advocate for most proceedings.
Which GST notice have you received, and how is it defended?
The form number on the notice decides the reply form, the deadline and the defence, so identify it first. Confusing a scrutiny notice with a show-cause notice can mean missing a much shorter reply window. These cards summarise the five notices we see most often in Chennai.
DRC-01A / DRC-01
Show-cause notice under Section 73, 74 or 74A
- What it means
- DRC-01A is the pre-notice intimation; DRC-01 is the summary of the formal show-cause notice. Sections 73 and 74 cover FY 2023-24 and earlier; Section 74A covers FY 2024-25 onwards.
- How to respond
- Object in Part B of DRC-01A, or reply to the show-cause notice in DRC-06 within the time stated (usually 30 days) and ask for a personal hearing.
- What the defence rests on
- Limitation, whether fraud or suppression is actually made out, invoice-level reconciliation, and the officer's jurisdiction.
ASMT-10
Scrutiny mismatch: GSTR-3B vs GSTR-2B, GSTR-1 vs e-way bills
- What it means
- The officer has found discrepancies while scrutinising your returns. No demand has been raised yet.
- How to respond
- Reply in ASMT-11 within the time allowed, explaining or accepting each discrepancy. This early stage is handled by our GST notice reply service.
- What the defence rests on
- Line-by-line reconciliation: timing differences, credit notes, amendments in later returns, and supplier filing defaults.
Section 16(4), 16(5), 16(6)
ITC denied as time-barred
- What it means
- Credit is denied because it was claimed after the Section 16(4) deadline.
- How to respond
- Check whether Section 16(5) (FY 2017-18 to 2020-21 credit claimed in returns filed up to 30 November 2021) or Section 16(6) (registrations cancelled and later revoked) applies before replying or appealing.
- What the defence rests on
- The retrospective relief in Sections 16(5) and 16(6), the return in which credit was actually claimed, and the date of revocation.
MOV-06 / MOV-07 / MOV-09
Goods or vehicle detained in transit (Section 129)
- What it means
- MOV-06 is the detention order, MOV-07 the notice proposing tax and penalty, MOV-09 the order of demand. Common on routes into Chennai such as the Chennai-Bengaluru highway and the Ennore port and Red Hills approaches.
- How to respond
- Reply to MOV-07 within 7 days; secure release by paying the penalty or furnishing security; appeal the MOV-09 order in APL-01 with 10% of the penalty as pre-deposit.
- What the defence rests on
- Whether the defect was a technical lapse, such as a clerical e-way bill error or lapsed validity, with no intent to evade tax.
REG-17 / REG-19 / REG-21
GST registration cancelled by the officer
- What it means
- REG-17 proposes cancellation, usually for non-filing; REG-19 is the cancellation order.
- How to respond
- Reply to REG-17 in REG-18 within 7 working days. After a REG-19 order, apply for revocation in REG-21, generally within 90 days, once pending returns and dues are cleared.
- What the defence rests on
- Proof that the business is operating, returns filed (or filed late with cause), and whether the notice was properly served.
Which Chennai GST offices and appellate forums do we appear before?
As practising Chartered Accountants, we appear under Section 116 of the CGST Act before every Central and State GST forum in Chennai, up to the GST Appellate Tribunal. Whether your GSTIN is allotted to the Centre or the State decides which offices handle your case.
| Stage | Forum and location | What is heard there |
|---|
| Central GST adjudication | Chennai North, Chennai South and Chennai Outer Commissionerates (CBIC Chennai zone) | Show-cause notices and orders for taxpayers allotted to the Centre |
| Central GST first appeal | Commissioner (Appeals-I), Mahatma Gandhi Road, Nungambakkam, Chennai 600034, and Commissioner (Appeals-II), Newry Towers, Anna Nagar, Chennai 600040 | APL-01 appeals against Central GST orders. Newry Towers is a short walk from our J-Block office |
| State GST adjudication | Tamil Nadu Commercial Taxes Department, Integrated Commercial Taxes Building, Nandanam, Chennai | Show-cause notices and orders for taxpayers allotted to the State |
| State GST first appeal | Appellate Deputy Commissioners (ST), PAPJM Building, Greams Road, Chennai | APL-01 appeals against State GST orders |
| Second appeal | GST Appellate Tribunal, Chennai State Bench | APL-05 appeals: Category I matters (classification, ITC, refunds, valuation) and Category II matters (registration, Section 73/74 proceedings, penalties) |
Office locations as published by the CBIC Chennai zone (gstchennai.gov.in) and the Tamil Nadu Commercial Taxes Department (ctd.tn.gov.in). The authority and address printed on your notice or order always govern.
What are the stages of GST litigation?
- 1
Show-Cause Notice (SCN) Reply
We analyse the SCN, gather supporting documentation, and draft a legally grounded reply within the time allowed in the notice, typically 30 days.
- 2
Departmental Audit & Assessment
We represent you during GST audits (Section 65/66) and assessment proceedings, coordinating document production and officer queries.
- 3
Appeal before Appellate Authority
If the order is adverse, we file a first appeal in Form GST APL-01 on the GST portal before the Appellate Authority (Additional or Joint Commissioner (Appeals), or Commissioner (Appeals), depending on the rank of the officer who passed the order) within 3 months of communication of the order, with the admitted amount paid in full and a 10% pre-deposit of the disputed tax. A self-certified copy of the order is needed only where the order was not uploaded on the GST portal, and must then be submitted within 7 days of filing.
- 4
GST Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT)
If the Appellate Authority's order is still adverse, we file a second appeal in Form GST APL-05 on the GSTAT e-filing portal within 3 months, with a further 10% pre-deposit. GSTAT has a Principal Bench in New Delhi for matters involving place-of-supply disputes, and State Benches, which for Tamil Nadu sit at Chennai, Coimbatore and Madurai, for other matters.
- 5
ITC & Refund Dispute Defense
We build the factual and documentary case to defend legitimate ITC claims and pursue refund entitlements through litigation where needed.
For what typically happens between filing a reply and receiving an order, read what happens after you reply to a GST show cause notice.
What are the GST appeal time limits and pre-deposits?
Each step up the appeal ladder has its own limitation period and pre-deposit. The pre-deposit caps were reduced by the Finance (No. 2) Act, 2024, and the Finance Act, 2025 replaced the earlier 25% pre-deposit for e-way bill penalty orders with 10% of the penalty for any penalty-only order, from 1 October 2025. The Delhi High Court has held, in Gaurav Jain & Anr. v. Joint Commissioner (Appeals-II), CGST Delhi Zone & Anr., W.P.(C) 8414/2026, decided on 31 July 2026, that the 10% penalty pre-deposit does not apply to a first appeal against a penalty-only order where the show-cause notice was issued before 1 October 2025. That case concerned a penalty under Section 122(1A), not a Section 129 detention order, which carried a 25% pre-deposit before the change. It is a Delhi High Court ruling, so check how it applies to your own dates and forum.
| Stage | Forum | Time limit and form | Pre-deposit |
|---|
| 1. Adjudication (SCN and order) | Proper officer of the Central or State GST administration | Reply within the time in the SCN (usually 30 days); order in Form DRC-07 | None. Paying the tax before or soon after the SCN can reduce penalty |
| 2. First appeal | Appellate Authority (Section 107) | 3 months from communication of the order, condonable by 1 more month. Form APL-01 on the GST portal | Admitted amount in full plus 10% of disputed tax, capped at ₹20 crore CGST and ₹20 crore SGST (₹40 crore IGST). Penalty-only orders: 10% of the penalty |
| 3. Second appeal | GST Appellate Tribunal: State Bench, or Principal Bench for place-of-supply issues (Section 112) | 3 months from communication of the appellate order, condonable by 3 more months. Form APL-05 on the GSTAT e-filing portal | A further 10% of the tax still in dispute, capped at ₹20 crore CGST and ₹20 crore SGST (₹40 crore IGST). Penalty-only orders: a further 10% of the penalty |
| 4. High Court | Madras High Court, at Chennai or its Madurai Bench (Section 117) | 180 days from the State Bench order; only on a substantial question of law | As directed by the court; writ petitions remain available for jurisdiction and natural-justice issues |
| 5. Supreme Court | Supreme Court of India (Section 118) | Against High Court judgments in appeal, or directly against Principal Bench orders | As directed by the court |
Work out your own dates and pre-deposit with the GST appeal deadline and pre-deposit calculator. Source: Sections 107, 112, 117 and 118 of the CGST Act as amended, available on cbic-gst.gov.in. The pre-deposit is computed on tax only; disputed interest and penalty are not counted, except for penalty-only orders. For older orders, the Government notified a special last date for GSTAT appeals, which the GSTAT announced as extended to 31 July 2026. That date has passed; appeals against later orders follow the normal 3-month limit, condonable by 3 more months.
How much pre-deposit is needed for a first appeal and a GSTAT appeal?
A first appeal needs the admitted amount plus 10% of the disputed tax; a GSTAT appeal needs a further 10% of the tax still in dispute. Each 10% is capped at ₹20 crore under the CGST Act. Where an order demands only a penalty, such as a Section 129 detention order, the deposit is 10% of the penalty at each stage.
| Appeal | Tax demands | Cap on the 10% | Penalty-only orders | Once paid |
|---|
| First appeal (Section 107(6)) | The admitted amount in full, plus 10% of the remaining tax in dispute | ₹20 crore under the CGST Act, reduced from ₹25 crore by the Finance (No. 2) Act, 2024 | 10% of the penalty, from 1 October 2025 (Finance Act, 2025) | Recovery of the balance is deemed stayed while the appeal is pending (Section 107(7)) |
| GSTAT appeal (Section 112(8)) | The admitted amount in full, plus a further 10% of the remaining tax in dispute, over and above the first-appeal deposit | ₹20 crore under the CGST Act, reduced from ₹50 crore by the Finance (No. 2) Act, 2024, which also cut the rate from 20% to 10% | A further 10% of the penalty, from 1 October 2025 (Finance Act, 2025) | Recovery of the balance is deemed stayed until the appeal is disposed of (Section 112(9)) |
Source: Sections 107 and 112 of the CGST Act as amended, on CBIC's tax information portal (Section 107, Section 112). The pre-deposit is paid before filing, and if the appeal succeeds it is refunded with interest under Section 115.
Two cases need extra care. For demands from FY 2024-25 onwards, check first whether the order under Section 74A was passed within its time limit, because limitation can be the strongest ground of appeal. For goods detained in transit, our guide to Section 129 detention, release and appeal explains how the penalty-only rule applies. To work out the last date and the amount for your own order, use the GST appeal deadline and pre-deposit calculator.
Where does GSTAT sit in Tamil Nadu?
The official State Benches list on gstat.gov.in shows three locations for Tamil Nadu: Chennai, Coimbatore (also listed as a sitting) and Madurai. Puducherry is listed separately, with a circuit sitting at Puducherry. The tribunal hears second appeals against first appellate orders, and the bench is assigned on the GSTAT e-filing portal.
According to GSTAT Office Order No. 4/GSTAT/PB/2026 dated 29 July 2026, as reported, the roster from 1 August 2026 is:
- • Chennai: Category I matters (classification, ITC, refunds, valuation, assessment and similar) on Mondays and Tuesdays; Category II matters (registration, Section 73/74 proceedings, penalties and residual matters) on Wednesdays.
- • Coimbatore: Categories I and II on Thursdays.
- • Madurai: Categories I and II on the first, second and third Fridays of each month.
- • Puducherry (circuit bench): Categories I and II on the fourth and fifth Fridays.
Sittings and member composition change by office order, and the bench that hears your appeal is fixed by the GSTAT e-filing portal, not by where your business is. Always confirm the bench and hearing date on the GSTAT portal. Our explainer on the GST Appellate Tribunal for Chennai businesses covers how the tribunal works in more detail.
What do Tamil Nadu businesses ask about the GSTAT?
Most questions are about which bench will hear the appeal, how it is filed, the time limit, the fee and whether a small demand is worth taking to the tribunal. The answers below come from Sections 109 and 112 of the CGST Act, Rule 110 of the CGST Rules and the GSTAT's own list of State Benches.
Which GSTAT benches are officially listed for Tamil Nadu?
The State Benches list on gstat.gov.in shows three locations for Tamil Nadu: Chennai, Coimbatore (also listed as a sitting) and Madurai. Puducherry appears as a separate entry, with its own location and circuit sitting at Puducherry. The bench that hears a particular appeal is assigned through the GSTAT e-filing portal.
How is an appeal filed before the GSTAT?
The appeal is filed electronically in Form GST APL-05 under Rule 110, on the GSTAT e-filing portal; manual filing was removed from 22 September 2025. A provisional acknowledgement issues in Part A of APL-02A, and the final acknowledgement with the appeal number in Part B once any defects are cured.
What is the time limit for a GSTAT appeal?
Three months from the date the first appellate order is communicated, or from a date the Government notifies for filing GSTAT appeals, whichever is later (Section 112(1)). The Tribunal can admit an appeal filed within a further three months if you show sufficient cause for the delay (Section 112(6)).
What fee is payable on a GSTAT appeal?
Rule 110(5) fixes the fee at ₹1,000 for every ₹1 lakh of tax, input tax credit, difference in tax or credit, or fine, fee or penalty involved, with a minimum of ₹5,000 and a maximum of ₹25,000. An appeal against an order with no demand pays a flat ₹5,000. The pre-deposit is separate.
Can the GSTAT refuse to hear a small appeal?
Yes. Under Section 112(2), the Tribunal may, at its discretion, refuse to admit an appeal where the tax or input tax credit involved, the difference in tax or credit, or the fine, fee or penalty in the order does not exceed ₹50,000. Below that amount, weigh the cost of the appeal first.
Which appeals go to the Principal Bench instead?
Appeals where one of the issues involved is the place of supply go to the Principal Bench in New Delhi, not to a State Bench. Every other appeal from Tamil Nadu goes to a State Bench. If your appeal raises place of supply along with other issues, plan for a Principal Bench hearing.
Sources: GSTAT State Benches · Rule 110, CGST Rules · Section 112, CGST Act. The order being appealed and the GSTAT portal always govern the dates and the bench.
What GST disputes are common in Tamil Nadu?
Tamil Nadu taxpayers are administered either by the Central GST commissionerates or by the State Commercial Taxes Department, but the disputes look much the same. These are the ones we see most often:
| Dispute | What usually triggers it | What the defence rests on |
|---|
| ITC mismatch: GSTR-2B vs GSTR-3B | Credit claimed in GSTR-3B exceeds what suppliers reported, usually because a supplier filed late, amended an invoice or failed to file | Invoice-wise reconciliation, proof of payment to the supplier, supplier's later returns and correspondence |
| Section 16(4) time limit | ITC claimed after the deadline (the November return following the financial year end, or the annual return if earlier) | Check whether the relief in Section 16(5) for FY 2017-18 to 2020-21, or Section 16(6) for revoked registrations, applies |
| Fake or non-existent supplier invoices | Credit denied because a supplier is found non-existent or its registration is cancelled with retrospective effect | Evidence of actual receipt of goods: e-way bills, transport records, weighbridge slips, stock entries, banking trail |
| Classification and rate | Department proposes a higher rate under a different HSN or SAC entry, including disputes about the September 2025 rate changes | Product literature, trade usage, technical write-ups, earlier rulings and the chapter notes |
| E-way bill detention (Section 129) | Goods detained in transit for a missing, expired or mismatched e-way bill, with penalty demanded for release | Prompt reply to the detention notice; appeal against the order, where the pre-deposit is 10% of the penalty |
| Section 73 / 74 / 74A demand | Short payment, wrong ITC or erroneous refund. Sections 73 and 74 cover FY 2023-24 and earlier; Section 74A applies from FY 2024-25 | Limitation check (Section 74A allows 42 months from the annual return due date), and whether the fraud allegation is actually supported |
Classification disputes
Disagreements over the HSN/SAC code and applicable tax rate for your goods or services.
Valuation disputes
Challenges to the transaction value declared, especially in related-party or discounted transactions.
Place of supply disputes
Disagreements over whether a supply is intra-state or inter-state, affecting CGST/SGST vs. IGST liability.
Input Tax Credit (ITC) disputes
Denial or reversal of ITC due to supplier non-compliance, mismatch in GSTR-2B, or blocked credit provisions.
Exemption disputes
Challenges to claimed exemptions or concessional rates under notifications.
Refund litigation
Delayed, rejected, or partially sanctioned refund claims for exports, inverted duty structure, or excess tax paid.
Our take: ITC mismatch notices are, in our experience, the most common trigger for a GST show-cause notice among Chennai SMEs and traders, usually because a supplier filed their return late or incorrectly, not because of anything the recipient business did wrong. The fix is rarely “pay the demand” it's proving the mismatch sits with the supplier's filing, which requires pulling GSTR-2B history and correspondence, not just arguing the point. Our guide to ITC mismatch notices explains the reconciliation. For demands raised from FY 2024-25, see how Section 74A time limits and penalties work, and for goods stopped in transit, goods detained under Section 129: release and appeal.
How are GST appeals filed online?
- 1. First appeal (APL-01): filed on the GST portal (gst.gov.in) under Services, User Services, My Applications, against the demand order. The pre-deposit is paid from the cash or credit ledger, or by DRC-03, and linked in the form. A provisional acknowledgement (APL-02) is generated, and the order is issued in APL-04.
- 2. Second appeal (APL-05): filed on the GSTAT e-filing portal (efiling.gstat.gov.in), using the ARN of the APL-01 appeal. Grounds, statement of facts, the orders below, proof of pre-deposit and the fee receipt are uploaded, and the appeal is signed with a DSC or Aadhaar e-sign.
- 3. Hearings: notices and orders arrive on the portal. Appellate Authorities in Tamil Nadu may hold personal hearings in person or by video; GSTAT hearings follow the bench roster.
What documents do you need for a GST appeal?
| Document | Why it matters |
|---|
| Show-cause notice and DRC-01A, if any | Defines the allegation, the section invoked and the period covered |
| Order (DRC-07) or appellate order (APL-04) | Fixes the limitation date and the amount in dispute for the pre-deposit |
| Your reply and personal hearing records | Shows what was argued below; new grounds at appeal need justification |
| GSTR-1, GSTR-3B, GSTR-2A/2B and GSTR-9 for the period | Basis for reconciling turnover and ITC figures |
| Invoices, e-way bills, transport and payment proof | Proves that supplies actually took place and that suppliers were paid |
| Contracts, purchase orders, product literature | Needed for classification, valuation and place-of-supply disputes |
| Pre-deposit payment proof (DRC-03 or ledger debit) | An appeal is not admitted without the required pre-deposit |
| Authorisation for the representative | Letter of authority for a Chartered Accountant under Section 116 |
How do we work on a GST litigation matter?
We start by reading the notice or order itself before touching your books, the exact section cited (73, 74 or 74A, for instance) and the specific allegation determine both the reply deadline and the documents we pull first. From there we reconcile the disputed period against your GSTR-2B, e-way bills, and underlying invoices to build a factual position, draft the reply or appeal memorandum grounded in that reconciliation, and represent you personally at hearings under Section 116 of the CGST Act rather than handing the matter to a separate advocate. Every deadline, the SCN reply window, the 3-month appeal limitation, the pre-deposit payment, is tracked and flagged to you in writing, not left for you to calculate.
Why does a Chennai-based CA matter in GST litigation?
Much of the visible online content on GST litigation is written for a national audience. A Chennai-based CA firm works with the procedures of the Chennai GST Commissionerates and the Tamil Nadu appellate authorities regularly, and is close enough to meet you in person while a reply or appeal is being prepared.
Do we handle GST litigation across Tamil Nadu?
Yes. Our only office is in Anna Nagar, Chennai, and we have no branch elsewhere. Replies and appeals are filed online, and hearings are attended by video where the authority permits or in person by arrangement. Each city page below covers the industries and disputes typical of that area: