An ASMT-10 on the GST portal means an officer has scrutinised your returns for a year and found figures that do not reconcile. It is not a demand yet. It is a request to explain, and a well-supported reply can close the matter with no tax, interest or penalty beyond what is genuinely due. A missed or vague reply tends to turn the same figures into a show cause notice. This post explains the law, the time limit and how to build the reply.
What is an ASMT-10 scrutiny notice?
Section 61 of the CGST Act allows the proper officer to scrutinise the return and related particulars to verify their correctness, inform the registered person of any discrepancies and seek an explanation. Rule 99 of the CGST Rules sets the procedure: where a return is selected for scrutiny and a discrepancy is found, the officer issues a notice in Form ASMT-10, informing you of it, seeking your explanation and, where possible, quantifying the tax, interest and any other amount involved.
The text is on CBIC's tax information portal: Section 61 and Rule 99. Section 61 itself sets no deadline for issuing an ASMT-10, but any demand that follows must still fall within the limits in Sections 73, 74 or 74A for the year concerned.
What is the time limit to reply to ASMT-10, and can it be extended?
The reply is due within the time stated in the notice, which under Rule 99(1) cannot exceed thirty days from the date of service, "or such further period as may be permitted by him". Section 61(3) uses the same thirty days and the same extension wording. Neither sets a cap on the extension, so it is the officer's call. Ask in writing before the original date runs out.
For Central Tax officers, CBIC's Instruction No. 02/2023-GST dated 26 May 2023 sets internal timelines for scrutiny of returns for FY 2019-20 onwards:
| Event | Timeline in the SOP |
|---|---|
| Reply in ASMT-11 | Within 30 days of ASMT-10, or a further period permitted by the officer |
| ASMT-12 accepting the reply | Within 30 days of receiving the ASMT-11 reply |
| Demand proceedings under Section 73 or 74 where no reply is filed | Within 15 days after the 30-day (or extended) period |
| Demand proceedings where the reply is not accepted | Within 30 days of receiving the reply |
| Reference to audit or anti-evasion (Sections 65, 66 or 67) | Within 30 days of the reply, or 45 days of ASMT-10 if no reply |
These are departmental timelines, not a limitation period that voids a late notice. They do show how quickly a silent ASMT-10 can turn into a demand. The SOP refers to Sections 73 and 74 because it predates Section 74A; Section 61(3) now also names Section 74A.
How do officers select returns and frame the notice?
Under the CBIC SOP, the Directorate General of Analytics and Risk Management selects GSTINs for scrutiny on risk parameters, and the officer works through the scrutiny module on the ACES-GST application. The SOP asks officers to scrutinise all returns for the selected year and issue a single compiled ASMT-10, to make the discrepancies specific rather than vague, to upload worksheets, and to take DRC-03 payments already made into account. It also says there should normally be no need to seek documents from the taxpayer before ASMT-10 is issued.
Instruction No. 02/2023-GST applies to Central Tax officers; returns for FY 2017-18 and 2018-19 stay under the earlier Instruction No. 02/2022-GST. A Tamil Nadu business assigned to the state administration receives the same forms under the same Section 61 and Rule 99, and the reply points below apply either way.
What data does the officer compare before issuing ASMT-10?
The SOP says the officer may rely on the returns and statements you have filed and on data from sources such as DGARM, ADVAIT, GSTN and the e-way bill portal. It also cautions that the risk data on the dashboard is a snapshot and may change after later filings by you or your suppliers, so officers are told to use the latest data. In practice the discrepancies tend to come from comparisons like these:
- Outward supplies in GSTR-1 against tax paid in GSTR-3B for the same months.
- Input tax credit claimed in GSTR-3B against credit shown in GSTR-2B.
- Turnover and tax in the annual return against the monthly or quarterly returns.
- E-way bills generated against supplies declared in returns.
If a supplier has filed or amended returns since the notice data was drawn, show the updated position. A difference that has since disappeared from the portal is often the quickest item to close.
What are your options when replying in ASMT-11?
Rule 99(2) gives you two routes, which can be combined issue by issue. You can accept a discrepancy, pay the tax, interest and any other amount arising from it, and inform the officer. Or you can furnish an explanation. Both go in Form ASMT-11 on the common portal.
Accepting is not the end of it. Section 61(3) also allows action where a taxpayer accepts a discrepancy but fails to take the corrective measure in the return for the month in which it is accepted, and the SOP treats failure to pay accepted amounts the same way. If you accept, pay through DRC-03 and record the reference in ASMT-11.
When is the scrutiny closed in ASMT-12?
Under Rule 99(3), where the explanation or the information on payment is found acceptable, the officer informs you in Form ASMT-12. Section 61(2) adds that no further action shall be taken in that regard. Keep the ASMT-12 with the year's file: it is your record that the issues in the ASMT-10 were closed at the scrutiny stage.
What happens if the explanation is not accepted?
Section 61(3) lets the officer initiate appropriate action including audit by tax authorities under Section 65, special audit under Section 66, or inspection, search and seizure under Section 67, or proceed to determine the tax under Section 73 or 74, or Section 74A, inserted by the Finance (No. 2) Act, 2024.
| Route after scrutiny | Provision | What it means for you |
|---|---|---|
| Demand for FY 2017-18 to FY 2023-24 | Section 73 (non-fraud) or Section 74 (fraud, suppression) | Show cause notice summarised in DRC-01; reply in DRC-06 |
| Demand for FY 2024-25 onwards | Section 74A | One provision with a 42-month notice window; reply in DRC-06 |
| Audit | Section 65 or special audit under Section 66 | Wider examination of books and records for the period |
| Investigation | Section 67 | Inspection, search and seizure by the anti-evasion wing |
Before a notice, the officer may also send a DRC-01A intimation. Our posts on the DRC-01A intimation and the Section 74A GST notice cover those stages.
How should you reply to an ASMT-10, step by step?
- Diarise the reply date. Note the date of service, the period stated and the financial year covered.
- Download the notice and worksheets. Map each discrepancy to its parameter and the officer's figure.
- Rebuild each figure from your records. Reconcile GSTR-1, GSTR-3B, GSTR-2B and GSTR-9 with the books for the year. Our guide to ITC mismatch notices covers the common credit differences.
- Split the amount. Separate what is genuinely payable from what is explained by amendments, credit notes, timing or the supplier's filing.
- Pay the accepted part through DRC-03. Pay tax with interest and keep the reference for the reply.
- Ask for more time if needed. Before the deadline, in writing, with a reason.
- File ASMT-11 on the portal. Answer issue by issue with numbered annexures, and keep the acknowledgement.
- Follow up. Watch for ASMT-12, a DRC-01A or a show cause notice, and act on whichever arrives.
What should an ASMT-11 reply checklist include?
- Header: legal name, GSTIN, ASMT-10 reference and date, financial year
- Summary table: each discrepancy, the officer's figure, your figure and the reason for the difference
- Reconciliations: GSTR-1 vs GSTR-3B, GSTR-2B vs GSTR-3B, and books vs returns, with the annual return figures
- Evidence: invoices, credit notes, ledgers, e-way bills or supplier confirmations for each item
- Payments: DRC-03 references, dates and amounts mapped to the issues accepted
- Corrective action: where a discrepancy is accepted, the return in which it has been corrected
- Points of law: any discrepancy the notice does not specify, or a figure with no worksheet behind it
- Request: that the explanation be accepted and the proceedings closed in ASMT-12
How is ASMT-10 different from DRC-01A and DRC-01?
| Point | ASMT-10 | DRC-01A | DRC-01 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Legal basis | Section 61; Rule 99 | Rule 142(1A) | Section 73, 74 or 74A; Rule 142(1) |
| Nature | Discrepancies found in scrutiny of returns | Optional intimation of an amount before a notice | Summary of a show cause notice demanding tax |
| Your response | Explanation or payment in ASMT-11 | DRC-03 payment and/or reply in Part B | Reply in DRC-06, with a hearing request |
| Closed by | ASMT-12 | Part C accepting payment or submissions | Order in DRC-07, or DRC-05 after payment |
| If unresolved | Audit, investigation or a demand | Show cause notice | Order, then appeal |
Each stage narrows the room to correct figures informally. If an adverse order follows, the appeal stages are set out on our GST litigation page, and routine return work is covered under goods and services tax. For the first steps once a show cause notice arrives, see what to do in the first 48 hours. C S Rushil & Co. prepares ASMT-11 replies and the reconciliations behind them from Anna Nagar, Chennai, and online, as part of its GST notice reply service.